Board Thread:Wiki Improvements/@comment-4146635-20131207205009/@comment-5384369-20131208041131

Frankly, because I'm me, I have to take the other side. Just because.

Although transcripts are long and time consuming to complete, it's not really a reason for why they shouldn't be there. I mean, I remember seeing the Backups & Breakups page have no episode summary until like.... January/ February... and it aired in October... So.... like 3-4 months...

Also, even though people might not edit them as often as they edit the Auslly page or a new episode page, they still are edited none the less.

I'm sorry, but I have no idea what "...not everyone can or knows where to watch the episode like that." really means. It just confused me. I mean, if you mean that people aren't able to access (full) episodes to the actual episode, then I feel like that would be somewhat contradictory to your current argument. I mean, if people can't watch them.... at least they can read them.

Also, we have I think 65 articles we've called subs, and in my opinion, also meaning "incomplete". I really don't think a few more pages will really damage anything.

The topic of relevance is certainly a fragile ground to trend upon. I mean, I can name a few articles on that can be categorized as "irrelevant". Or at least, it doesn't need a whole page. I mean, look at the MyTewb page. It has had 2 edits made to it. Or look at the Mr. De la Rosa page. Seriously? I mean that dude was just there to be their. He didn't even have any lines. Or the Kevin Chamberlin page. At least the transcripts provided some sort of context, or at least more relevance than some of the other articles that this wiki contains.

I have to say. The "memorable quotes" section can get pretty long. The transcript is pretty much the giant ultimate version of the "memorable quotes" section. The idea of an edit or working on something only for it to result in being "all for nothing", I have to say can be applied to a number of situations. I mean, I have been editing some pages just where there's a space and then a comma when there shouldn't be a space at all. Not very many people care about that sort of stuff and it's normally passed over. But I wouldn't call my edit as nothing. It may not have drastically changed a person's view or whatever, but I still edited it anyways.

Also, changing the words on a page to something different can happen to any page really, it doesn't really just apply to a certain type of page. Although it would be more difficult to identify a mistake on a transcript, there are mistakes on practically every page anyways.

The idea of picking which quotes are necessarily "important or funny" is completely based on a person's opinion. I mean, I just went to the Rockers & Writers/Transcript page and it didn't take that long to find a quote that made me smile that in fact was not in the Memorable quotes section.

So what if transcripts aren't these big drastic meaningful pages. They still have some relevance than other have.

I mean, what real harm is there to a transcript anyway?